1. Welcome to PHCorner Forums. Take a moment to Sign up and gain unlimited access and extra privileges that guests are not entitled to, such as:

    All that and more! Registration is quick, simple and absolutely free. Join our community today!

5 Historic Lies You Were Taught In School

Discussion in 'Off-Topic' started by Jeanh, Aug 26, 2015.

  1. We’ve all heard about history textbooks in public schools being rife with typographical errors and grammar mistakes. But that pales in comparison with historical myths that have been taught in primary schools as if they actually existed.

    Calling them ‘historical lies’ may be a bit too harsh, but I can’t think of any word to describe seemingly historical errors that have been blown out of proportion.

    Perhaps you still believe them. Or maybe your old elementary teacher still does. Either way, it’s time to separate myth from fact once and for all.

    Here are 5 of the most ridiculous Philippine historical myths you thought were true:

    1. Ferdinand Magellan was the first person to circumnavigate the world
    Please or Register to view links
    Ferdinand Magellan (1480 – 1521)

    The story you heard:

    After conquering Malacca, Sumatra in 1511, Portuguese explorer Fernão de Magalhães (Anglicized as Ferdinand Magellan) once again reached Southeast Asia in 1521 in search of the Maluku (Spice Islands). And that made him the first person to travel around the world. Or so we thought.

    The truth:

    We all know that after intervening in the Please or Register to view links, Magellan was butchered to death by the latter and didn’t live to be the “first person to circumnavigate the world”. Now, if Magellan was not the first person to circumnavigate the world, who did?

    Historical evidences show us two stronger candidates: Sebastian Elcano and Magellan’s nameless slave-cum-interpreter who was later baptized as Please or Register to view links

    Obviously, Elcano was the one who got the fame and fortune. Recognized by King Charles I as the first person to circle the Earth, Elcano received a yearly pension as well as a coat of arms featuring a globe that has the Latin inscription Primus circumdedisti me or “you went around me first.”

    However, several historians argue that if Enrique, Magellan’s slave, originally came from Sumatra as what records show, then he would have already circumnavigated the world by the time the Portuguese fleet reached the Philippine shores.

    Magellan’s last will indicated that Enrique was bought from Malacca and reportedly spoke the Malay language, making him an invaluable part of Magellan’s journey to the Southeast.

    On the other hand, the expedition’s chronicler, Antonio Pigafetta, wrote that Enrique was actually a native of Sumatra. Another witness, Gines de Mafra, also proved that Enrique indeed spoke Malay to the Filipino islanders–a claim which led to a theory that the first person who circled the world could actually be a Filipino.

    However, it’s interesting to note that at that time, Malay was a common language of trade in most Southeast Asia, and not a dialect exclusive to the Philippines.

    After Magellan’s death, Enrique remained in the Philippines after a conflict between him and the new leaders of the voyage. Whether or not he returned to his hometown–which would only take roughly two months of island-hopping–is still unverified.

    But if he was able to return to Sumatra less than 15 months before Pigafetta and other expedition survivors reached Spain, then Please or Register to view links.

    2. Princess Urduja and the legendary kingdom ofTawalisi
    Please or Register to view links
    A portrait of Princess Urduja (Source: Jaime Carlos de Veyra. 1951. Quien fue Urduja? un ser mitologico: estudio historico. manila: Nueva Eva Press)

    The story you heard:

    Urduja (ca. 1350–1400 AD) is a legendary princess who first appeared in the book Rihlah(Travels) by Ibn Batuta (1304 – 1378), an Arab traveler who was also a contemporary of Marco Polo.

    According to his accounts, he reached the land of Tawalisi (present-day Pangasinan) after 71 days in the sea and while on his way to China. In this island kingdom, Ibn Batuta allegedly met a brave amazon named Urduja who would only marry the man who could beat her in fistfights.

    Legend has it that the warrior princess later prepared a lavish banquet for Ibn Batuta and even gave him gifts of a lifetime which included silk, expensive spices, buffaloes , truckloads of rice and sheep among others.

    The truth:

    Although the story of Urduja was commonly featured in comics, môviês, TV shows and even history books, several scholars declared Urduja as a myth and her story a mere Please or Register to view links

    Aside from the lack of archaeological evidence to prove the existence of Urduja’s Shri-Visayan Empire, scholars also failed to discover any reference to Urduja in Spanish documents that chronicled the pre-Hispanic Philippines. In fact, Urduja never appeared in the Sucesos de las Islas Filipinas (1609) of Antonio de Morga, considered by many–Rizal included–as the most reliable source of pre-Hispanic accounts.

    Dr. Rosario Cortes, a UP professor who was also the first person to write a comprehensive history of Pangasinan, Please or Register to view links. Although he translated Ibn Batuta’s account from Arabic to English, Professor Charles Beckingham of London University described the story as too far from being “a genuine account of real journeys.”

    3. Fernando Poe Sr. served as a model for the U.P. Oblation
    Please or Register to view links

    The story you heard:

    The Oblation (or “Pahinungod” in Filipino) is a concrete statue that has become the iconic symbol of the Please or Register to view links and the promise of its students to offer themselves to the country.

    Measuring 3.5 meters in height, the original Oblation statue was first conceived during Rafael Palma’s presidency. It is said that Palma commissioned Please or Register to view links, then a professor at the UP School of Fine Arts, to complete the project.

    Tolentino allegedly convinced the late actor Fernando Poe Sr., who was a UP student at that time, to model for the Oblation. Soon, people started to believe that FPJ’s late father was indeed the man behind University of the Philippines’ famous sculpture.

    The truth:

    University literature, specifically the book by the late Please or Register to view links, revealed that it was not Fernando Poe Sr. who inspired the Oblation.

    More surprising is the fact that not only one but two people actually modeled for the iconic statue: Please or Register to view links, his student and assistant, and Virgilio Raymundo, his brother-in-law. To create the Oblation, Tolentino used Caedo’s physique and Raymundo’s proportion.

    Also Read: Please or Register to view links

    4. The first blood compact was between Rajah Sikatuna and Miguel López de Legazpi
    Please or Register to view links
    “El Pacto de Sangre” by Juan Luna (1886) shows the blood compact between Rajah Sikatuna of Bohol and Miguel López de Legazpi.

    The story you heard:

    The first treaty between the Philippines and another country happened on March 16, 1565 when Rajah Sikatuna made a blood compact (“Sanduguan”) with Miguel López de Legazpi in the presence of other conquistadors.

    In honor of this landmark event, The Order of Sikatuna was created in 1953 by Executive Order No. 571 signed by Please or Register to view links. A monument in Tagbilaran City, Bohol named “The Sandugo Blood Compact Site” was also built to commemorate the said historic pact.

    The truth:

    Although largely believed as true, the blood compact between Miguel López de Legazpi and Rajah Sikatuna was not the first in the country. The notion that it was the first treaty was soon refuted by the accounts of Antonio Pigafetta, an Italian chronicler who joined Magellan in his bloody voyage.

    If we are going to believe Pigafetta, the Please or Register to view links. This event happened on March 28, 1521 or almost 44 years before the event depicted in Juan Luna’s famous painting (see photo above).

    The first recorded treaty between Philippines and a foreign country, on the other hand, was between Magellan and Rajah Humabon’s nephew who was assisted by Raia Siaiu and 11 other men. The historic event happened on Tuesday, April 9, 1521.

    5. Datu Puti and the legend of The Ten Bornean Datus
    Please or Register to view links

    “Arrival of the 10 Bornean datus” by Ilonggo historical painter Art Geroche (source: Please or Register to view links)

    The story you heard:

    According to a prehistoric document we now know as Maragtas, ten Bornean datus led by Please or Register to view links left their kingdom around 1250 A.D. to escape the wrath of their heartless ruler, Sultan Makatunaw.

    Legend has it that the ten Bornean datus landed in the island of Panay, then inhabited by the Atis governed by a king named Marikudo. Although Please or Register to view links, the Bornean datus eventually bought the lowlands in exchange for a gold saduk or salakot (native hat) and a gold necklace for Queen Maningwantiwan.

    In the end, Datu Puti returned to Borneo while Datus Dumangsil and Balensusa settled with their families in the northern regions of Luzon, now known as Laguna and Bicol Peninsula.

    The other seven datus, on the other hand, remained in Panay and eventually divided the island into three regions. One of these datus was Datu Sumakwel who led the formation of a political organization called Confederation of Madjaas as well as a body of laws known as Maragtas.

    The Maragtas Code was previously known as the Please or Register to view links, predating Please or Register to view links which was officially declared by the National Historical Commission as a hoax.

    The truth:

    In his doctoral dissertation at UST, William Henry Scott (the same person who disproved the Code of Kalantiaw) revealed that Maragtas is not a actual prehistoric source. Instead, it is just a book written by a historian in Panay named Pedro Monteclaro.

    The author himself noted that his manuscripts were “rotten and hardly legible”. The book’s publisher, on the other hand, noted in 1907 that Maragtas should never be considered as facts.
Tags / Keywords: